Besides David Flair, Stacy Keibler was also romantically linked with the late Andrew "Test" Martin, but once the former Intercontinental Champion was released from WWE, their relationship ended. Some years later, Keibler would begin dating actor Geoff Stults (the ex-boyfriend who pranked her on "Punk'd") before having her highest profile relationship with two-time Academy Award winner, George Clooney. However, this relationship also didn't last, but Keibler would eventually meet her now-husband, Future Ads CEO Jared Pobre, tying the knot in 2014. Since then, the couple have welcomed three children, two daughters and a son.

Since stepping away from WWE, Keibler has rarely been associated with the promotion or the industry, save for inducting Torrie Wilson into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2019, and her own induction a few years later in 2023 by Wilson and pro wrestling legend Mick Foley. Based on her social media presence, Keibler has now become a social media influencer and brand ambassador for various products, where she shares her workouts, advocates for wellness through natural remedies, and often uploads videos of what she gets up to and moments with her husband and children.