The bell rings and Evans lands a superkick on Lee. Page lands a right hand on Evans, but Evans rolls him up. Lee then rolls up Evans, but Page breaks the fall. The trio continue taking turns pinning one another and landing dropkicks on each other, but Page lands a Fallaway Slam on Evans that sends him crashing into Lee on the apron and knocks him onto the floor. Page then follows it up with a boot to Evans and connects with a backbreaker before setting up for Ego's Edge.

Evans avoids it and pins Page, but Lee breaks the fall and pins Evans. Evans kicks out, and Lee fires off stomps on him. He then rains down right hands on him, but Evans responds with a pair of right hands. Lee and Evans then double team on Page to send him crashing out of the ring, but Evans lands a right hand on Lee that rocks him.

Evans runs the ropes, but Page trips him. Lee flies to take down Page on the outside and looks to land a Tornado DDT on him, but Page responds with a back body drop to him that sends him crashing onto the announce table. Evans then flies through the ropes to send himself and Page crashing over the announce desk.

Back from the break, Lee and Evans exchange right hands with one another in the ring. Lee turns Evans inside out with a clothesline, but Page fires off stomps on both of them and bodyslams Evans onto Lee. He sends Lee crashing on top of Evans, then sends Lee crashing into the ring post shoulder first and rains down right hand on Evans.

Page lands a powersam on Evans, then goes for a pin but Lee breaks the fall with a dropkick. Page, Evans, and Lee then exchange strikes with one another and take each other down with kicks before Page and Lee teeter on the ropes. Page knocks Lee off, but Evans joins him up there and connects with a Spanish Fly. He then delivers a roundhouse kick to Lee and goes for a pin, but Lee kicks out.

Page sets up for Ego's Edge on Eans, but Page avoids it. He then delivers a cutter off the middle rope to Lee and pins him, but Lee kicks out. Evans then ascends to the top, but Page clocks him from behind and sets up for Ego's Edge. Lee prevents Page from landing the move, but Page pulls him and Evans off the ropes. Evans then superkicks Page out of the ring and delivers a Tornillo to Lee off the ropes. He pins Lee, but Page sneaks back in the ring and pins Evans for the win.

Winner (and new Number One Contender): Ethan Page

After the match, Page tells Williams that he won't give up on chasing the NXT Championship as long as there's air in his lungs. He calls him down to the ring, and Williams appears. Page spins the wheel to determine the stipulation for their NXT Championship match at Halloween Havoc, and the wheel lands on a Devil's Playground match. Page then clocks Williams and stands tall on the entrance ramp as the show goes off the air.